Main Menu

Russia Pre-1900 (The Real Deal)

Started by Guinness, July 03, 2014, 09:44:52 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Guinness

I invite any and all to review what's posted in my encyclopedia, and comment here. Pretty much every ship there has changed, some that I posted before no longer exist, etc.

http://www.navalism.org/index.php/board,528.0.html

The Rock Doctor

If you have an opportunity to indicate which classes are deployed where, I'd focus my review on Black Sea stuff.

If not, I will review at my leisure...

snip

All of this is at a glance, so I might have missed some finer details.

Battleships: Looking good overall, I dont see anything illegal. Im assuming the 12"/40 are the historic gun, so thank you for matching shell weights. I would have gone for taller belts, but I am a well known ArmorWhore.

First-Rank Cruisers: Overall, nothing illegal. Might want to check the belt length on Admiral Nakhimov and General-Admiral, as there are nice tasty exposed vitals.

Second-Rank Cruiser: Not a bad looking ship.

Torpedo Boats: Get rid of the Torp listings from the weapons tab. Other then that, nothing objectionable.

CDS: Admiral Ushakov has two twin mounts for 2 guns.

Small Craft: Looks good.

Auxiliaries: Looks good.

Coastal Guns: I see nothing to object to given the scale of my defenses.
You smug-faced crowds with kindling eye
Who cheer when solider lads march by
Sneak home and pray that you'll never know
The hell where youth and laughter go.
-Siegfried Sassoon

Guinness

#3
Quote from: The Rock Doctor on July 03, 2014, 09:55:37 AM
If you have an opportunity to indicate which classes are deployed where, I'd focus my review on Black Sea stuff.

If not, I will review at my leisure...

Here's what I have in the working copy of the 1900 report. I don't think any ship assignments will change. All ships listed in Sevastapol are (obviously) in the Black Sea:

Quote

ClassNo.Disp.Laid DownCompleteLast RefitTypeLocationStatus
Tsesarevich (BB)310,500189018931893mKronstadta
Evstafi (BB)29,600189218961896mSevastapola
Borodino (BB)311,400189518981898mKronstadta
Potemkin (BB)111,100189618981898mSevastapola
Petropavlovsk (BB)311,500189819001900mKronstadta
Peresvet (BB)29,300189819001900mSevastapola
Rurik (1C)29,600189018931893mVladivostokm
Pamiat Azova (1C)17,900189218941894mKronstadta
Admiral Nakhimov (1C)18,500189418961896mKronstadta
General-Admiral (1C)29,900189819001900mKronstadta
Bayan (2C)45,500189618991899mKronstadt (2), Sevastapol (2)a
Bayan (2C)15,500189618991899mVladivostok (1)m
Pallada (3C)32,400189018921892mKronstadta
Vitiaz (3C)32,400189218941894mSevastapola
Varyag (3C)42,500189418961896mKronstadta
Ochakov (3C)42,600189618981898mKronstadta
Novik (3C)42,800189819001900mKronstadta
TB-115200189218951895mdKronstadt (10), Sevastapol (5)a
TB-1615200189618971897mdKronstadt (10), Sevastapol (5)a
TB-312300189618971897mdSevastapola
TB-338300189818981898mdKronstadta
Admiral Ushakov (CDS)13,200189418971897mVladivostokm
PB-14450189518981898cVarious Naval Installationsm
Mount Elbrus (Collier)42,100189018951895cBtwn Vladivostok and Kronstadtm
Alexandra Nikolaevna (Trans.)24,000189518971897cBtwn Vladivostok and Kronstadtm
Baltic Sea (Liner)110,000189218951895cSt. Petersburg - New York router
Kizi (Survey)5350189518961896cVariousm
Yermak (Icebreaker)15,200189518971897cThe Baltic (if it's winter)a
Turku (Icebreaker)12,300189819001900cThe Baltic (if it's winter)a

Guinness

Quote from: snip on July 03, 2014, 10:12:16 AM
First-Rank Cruisers: Overall, nothing illegal. Might want to check the belt length on Admiral Nakhimov and General-Admiral, as there are nice tasty exposed vitals.

Fixed. Both off by less than 10cm. That's what I get for going back to round off values...

Quote
Torpedo Boats: Get rid of the Torp listings from the weapons tab. Other then that, nothing objectionable.

Fixed.

Quote
CDS: Admiral Ushakov has two twin mounts for 2 guns.

Fixed.

Guinness

Rocky: I went ahead and noted where ships were constructed, etc. for you in the encyclopedia.

The Rock Doctor


Guinness

That class is explicitly to ominously threaten Constantinople.